HL7 International Logo_small Re-Circulation Request of HL7 Normative Ballot

 

Please use this form to submit the request to HL7 HQ: to the Director of Technical Publications and the Associate Executive Director ( ballotmanager@hl7.org and karenvan@hl7.org ). 

 

 

 

 

Date of this request:

 

HL7 Work Group making this request:

 

Name of the standard for which request is being made :

 

 

 

 

 

Ballot cycle in which the standard was successfully balloted:

 

Results of that ballot (following reconciliation activities):  

 

Vote

Number

Vote

Number

Affirmative

64

Not Returned

23

Negative

1

 

 

Abstentions

78

Total in ballot pool

166

 

Please attach the Negative ballot reconciliation document, which must include just the negative comments that remain at issue (declared not persuasive and not withdrawn), and that includes not just the WG's disposition but the WG vote (and the date of the meeting at which the disposition was voted upon). 

 

We will need the WG's rationale for the disposition finding for each of the negative comments that remains at issue.


Background:

One remaining NEG from Philip Burgher of Phillips Healthcare as noted below. Philip was emailed three times in the past two weeks from the ballot desktop with no response. He left the company last Friday 9/28/18. This disposition was voted on at the May WGM May 16 Q3, minutes: https://confluence.hl7.org/display/VOC/May+2018+-+HL7+WGM++-+Wednesday+Q3+Minutes

 

Comment

Disposition

Ballot comment

Move/Second

F o r

Against

Abstain

  Forgive the potential misunderstanding, but in general I believe users to understand a value set as defined by the set of codes included in it, i.e. the expansion. Changing the CLD to get a completely new expansion and not requiring a version upgrade seems like it will be prone to significant downstream effects without proper provenance

Not persuasive

The commenter misunderstands the requirements defined in the spec with regards to when a new value set definition is required. Please see section 5.2.3.2 Value Set Definition Version — Definitional Elements

Rob M / Russ H

6

0

0