Page History

Review of Blocks, comments and votes to date

Finalize Reconciliation of FHIR DS4P IG Ballot Reconciliation

Dispositions on Block 1 - 24 - Dispositions on Carmela Couderc's comments from MITRE were approved on Security call WG 11/17 https://confluence.hl7.org/pages/viewpage.action?pageId=97457934call 

Block 2 Comments 25 - 74 submitted by Celine Lefebvre for AMA were discussed with AMA representatives who tentatively accepted the dispositions.

Motion to Approve Block 2

Carie Hammond/Suzanne Gonzales Webb

7-0-0

Block 3 Comments 75 - 112 submitted by Christopher Shaut for Isaac Vetter and Michael Donnelly (EPIC) were discussed in part at the 202009 WGM but haven't been voted on.

Motion to Approve Block 3

Carie Hammond/Suzanne Gonzales Webb

7-0-0

Block 4 Comments 113 - 120 submitted by Craig Newman (Altarum) have not been discussed or voted on.

Motion to Approve Block 4

Suzanne Gonzales Webb/ Carie Hammond

7-0-0

Block 5 Comment 121 submitted by Genevieve Luensman (CDC) was discussed with the commenter and at the approved on Security WG 11/17 Security WG, and was approved by the WG.Block 6 call

Block 6  Comments 122 - 127 submitted by Servio Medina on behalf of Nancy Orvis (DOD-DHA) were discussed with a representative who indicated that the dispositions would be accepted.  Still need a vote.

Block 7 Comments 128 - 130  submitted by Rob McClure were discussed by email and tentatively accepted. Still need a vote.

Block 8 Comments 131 - 132 submitted by Jenni Syed (Cerner) have not been discussed or voted on.

Motion to Approve Block 8

Carie Hammond/Suzanne Gonzales Webb

6-0-0

Upload final FHIR DS4P IG 202005 Ballot Comment Spreadsheet to Ballot Desktop. Add dispositions, disposition comments, and vote counts to JIRA.  Revise Ballot comment as agreed.

On behalf of the Security WG, I want to thank the Kathleen thanked commenters for thoughtful and thorough review.  We will update the IG for the ballot to reflect approved dispositions.