Chairs:  Vanessa Candelora Rick Geimer 

Scribe:  Holli Murphy 
 

Agenda Topics


 Agenda Outline

Agenda Item

Meeting Minutes from Discussion

Management

Review ANSI Anti-Trust Policy

VC reviewed the anti-trust policy.

Housekeeping

Welcome back and Welcome any newcomers! 


Announcements

Upcoming HL7 Meetings, New Orleans, Louisiana

HL7 FHIR Connectathon, May 6-7, 2023

On 4/28, we will have our Connectathon Kick off the last 30min of this call. 


HL7 Working Group Meetings, May 8-12, 2023

New WGM+

These sessions at the May Working Group Meeting will help augment the typical standards development work happening in HL7's Working Groups and broaden the audience of those who wish to participate. Our theme for the meeting is policy as a driver of interoperability.

Register here

PCT WGM+ Session

Wednesday, May 10th, 1:45-3:00 CT

HL7 Da Vinci Project: Risk Adjustment IG / Patient Cost Transparency

· Vanessa Candelora, Senior Consultant, Point-of-Care Partners



May Ballot Cycle 

  • Commenting and voting happening now through May 1, 2023
  • Da Vinci Risk Adjustment Implementation Guide is included

Need help navigating? Review the HL7 Balloting Resources for Da Vinci Newcomers


Schedule



Project Use Case Update

Publication of PCT Standard For Trial Use 1 (STU1) guide is complete!!  Find the PCT STU1 here:  http://hl7.org/fhir/us/davinci-pct/ 

Thank you so much for all your participation to reach this major milestone!


Phase 2 Requirements (first 30min)

If you missed the PCT Phase 2 Kick off on February 3rd, see here for slides, recording and link to minutes: PCT Phase 2

See current slide deck below for ongoing discussion. Reminder: the goal is to define standard exchange for minimum viable requirements with space for optional, useful data to drive better estimates for patients without additional burden. 

1) Ask for any feedback here: Slides 19 - 20 Steps 4a and 4b (the GFE request notification and response from co-providers)

3) Review the GFE response - based requirements on the CMS form.

VC gave background for new participants.

SN: This scenario assumes that the hospital is the convening provider. Not sure it is clear how one determines who the convening provider will be. Not clearly defined in the regulation.

VC: Should we do a scenario where the surgeon is the convening provider?

Group agrees that we should.

ER: If we're looking at an out of network provider or a provider that needs to connect with an out of network payer, would there need to be a BAA (Business Associate Agreement) to conform to HIPAA or would it be enough to say that as the company providing the API we are in conformance and have appropriate security to conduct patient health information across established FHIR endpoints between us and the provider? Example, established patient with a primary care provider (convening provider) and they are trying to reach an out of network anesthesiologist.

SN: I think the transaction and the exchange of information is okay.

DS: Agree because it is for treatment. This scenario is for an uninsured patient.

Data Requirements - Step 5 (slide 21)

VC: Does it make sense for the co-providers to echo back the patient info? In our example its when the anesthesiologist would be giving the GFE information back to the convening provider through the coordination platform. Necessary or nice to have?

ZW: Nice to have.

VC: Any challenges with Step 5 that we haven't thought of?

MD: I think as long as the service linking identifier uniquely identifies the GFE back from the co-provider/co-facility, that is the assurance that it is the estimate for that patient.


Homework: Pleases review the attached deck and give us feedback on the work we've done to date.

Connectathon Kick off (last 30min)

Today, 4/28, we will have our Connectathon kick off in the last 30min of the call.

Reminder to Record!


Recording of Connectathon Kick off

Next Agenda



Next week we will start a new, alternative example.
 Chat


You 9:05 AM
Today's Agenda https://confluence.hl7.org/display/DVP/2023-04-28+Patient+Cost+Transparency+Meeting
Viet Nguyen  to  Everyone 9:05 AM
Working group meeting PLUS agenda - https://hl7.my.site.com/LightningMemberPortal/s/lt-event?id=a1Y7V00000YrACtUAN#/PLUS-Agenda
Wed: Q31:45 pm – 3:00 pm WGM+ HL7 Da Vinci Project: Risk Adjustment IG / Patient Cost Transparency Accelerator Working SessionsDa VinciWGM+ · Vanessa Candelora, Senior Consultant, Point-of-Care Partners HL7 Da Vinci Project: Risk Adjustment IG
rick.geimer  to  Everyone 9:07 AM
Connectathon kickoff slides now posted to today's call agenda page.
You  to  Everyone 9:07 AM
1:45-3:00 pm WGM+ HL7 Da Vinci Project: Risk Adjustment IG / Patient Cost Transparency Accelerator Working SessionsDa VinciWGM+ Fulton · Vanessa Candelora, Senior Consultant, Point-of-Care Partners HL7 Da Vinci Project: Risk Adjustment IG  Patient Cost Transparency - Vanessa Candelora
Viet Nguyen  to  Everyone 9:08 AM
Virtual registration is also discounted
You  to  Everyone 9:08 AM
This session is Wednesday, May 10th.
Vanessa Candelora (POCP)  to  Everyone 9:08 AM
Find the PCT STU1 here:  http://hl7.org/fhir/us/davinci-pct/
Rachel Foerster (RFA Ltd)  to  Everyone 9:09 AM
Viet, I'm confused re your reference to virtual registration - virtual for what?
jamie parker (AEGIS.net)  to  Everyone 9:10 AM
I am new to this group but not new to HL7 WG meetings
Rachel Foerster (RFA Ltd)  to  Everyone 9:14 AM
Never mind Viet. I am registered and have the agenda.
Stanley Nachimson, Nachimson Advisors 9:25 AM
Regarding the BAA question - if your company is representing the health plan, you should have your BAA with the plan.  Not sure you need a BAA with an OON provider; you are simply setting up a communication protocol, much as you are emailing them.

Viet Nguyen 9:31 AM
The term "period of care" made me ask if we had a reference. I found this - https://www.lawinsider.com/dictionary/period-of-care It references this document - https://evolutionmedicalassociates.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/01/HHS-notice-GOODFAITHESTIMATES-SELFPAY.pdf

Mike Denison, Optum 9:31 AM
https://www.cms.gov/CCIIO/Resources/Regulations-and-Guidance/Downloads/Guidance-Good-Faith-Estimate-Patient-Provider-Dispute-Resolution-Process-for-Providers-Facilities-CMS-9908-IFC.pdf
Chris Cioffi (Elevance Health) 9:32 AM
Need to drop for an internal call

Viet Nguyen 9:33 AM
Like a good terminologist...just create new terms!

Vanessa Candelora (POCP) 9:43 AM
If you are planning to attend the Connectathon PCT track, please let me know (privately if needed) what your interest is for testing, code you plan to bring, or just observing. We can pair testing partners and prepare the RI for testing with you.
You 9:49 AM
PCT FHIR Connectathon Track 2023 - 05 Da Vinci Patient Cost Transparency

Viet Nguyen 9:55 AM
Lots of great breakout too for observers
Viet Nguyen 9:56 AM
Also there's a Da Vinci Wrap-up on Sunday at 4pm

Viet Nguyen 9:57 AM
If you're new to the in person meeting, please find me and say hi!



Adjourned at 11:57 am ET

Supporting Documents

Action items 

  •  

Attendees 


Present

Name

Affiliation

PresentNameAffiliationPresentNameAffiliation
  •  

Aditya Pattnaik 

Onyx
  •  

Jackie Hemenway

UPMC
  •  
BCBSA
  •  

Alexandra Mugge

CMS
  •  
EPIC
  •  

Patrick Edwards

Arkansas BCBS
  •  
FL Blue
  •  

James Pittman

WPS
  •  
Paul Knapp 
  •  
Cambia Health
  •  

Jaime Lampshire

Cleveland Clinic
  •  
VA (Federal Electronic Health Record Management)
  •  
AHA
  •  
Jamie Farah FL Blue
  •  
Pragya Sharma
  •  
Ankit Kumar Agarwal
  •  

@Jamie Hermansen

CMS
  •  
Rachel E. Foerster 

Rachel Foerster & Associates, Ltd. (RFA)

  •  

Anoop Mohemmed

Humana
  •  
Jamie Parker AEGIS
  •  

Rahul Dewal


  •  
Ashley Barrow
  •  

Jeff Helman

AEGIS
  •  

Ranah Anan

Cognizant
  •  
Ashley Knox Cognizant
  •  
Optum
  •  
Elevance Health
  •  
Ashley BarrowRE-Assist
  •  

Jeff Mincher

Texas Health Resources
  •  


  •  

Balaji Narayanan

Onyx
  •  
Jennifer BoazBAH/HIIG
  •  
athenaHealth
  •  

Beth Davis


  •  
MCC
  •  
Rick Geimer Lantana
  •  
Bettina Vanover Cognizant
  •  
Jessica Czulewicz CMS
  •  
Rick Lisseveld AEGIS
  •  
Bhargav
  •  

Jill Elder

Providence
  •  
Lantana
  •  

HCA Healthcare

  •  

Weill Cornell Medicine

  •  
Robert Dieterle EnableCare
  •  


  •  
Interoperability Institute
  •  
Ronald Wampler CVS Health/Aetna
  •  
Merative
  •  
Joe Joseph Quinn Smile Digital Health
  •  
Ross SadlerHospital for Special Surgery
  •  


  •  
Josh LambOptum
  •  
Ryan Moehrke AEGIS
  •  
Smile Digital Health
  •  

Josh Loria

Teton Health
  •  
BCBSA
  •  
FL Blue
  •  


  •  

Sampath Jayaprakash


  •  
Carie Hammond AEGIS
  •  

Kaitlin Powers

CAQH CORE
  •  

Sarah Cutcliffe

Hospital for Special Surgery
  •  


  •  


  •  
Savanah ArceneauxOschner Health
  •  


  •  

Karen Roswon


  •  

Scott Haselton

Atlas
  •  
Celine Lefebvre AMA
  •  

Kassie Mintesnot


  •  

Scott Weinberg

CMS
  •  


  •  

Kathy Trubisky

AultCare Insurance Company
  •  
CMS
  •  
Elevance Health
  •  

Kayla Heath

AultCare Insurance Company
  •  

Shawn Wilson

FL Blue
  •  
BCBSAL
  •  


  •  
Sheryl Turney Elevance
  •  
Christol Green Elevance
  •  

Kendra May

CMS/CCIIO
  •  

Shouray

Onyx
  •  
Independent Health
  •  

Kenny W

Athena Health
  •  

Soham Chakraborty

Onyx
  •  
Corey Spears Lantana
  •  
Kevin Day Edifecs
  •  
Spencer Utley Epic
  •  

Crystal Ponder

FL Blue
  •  


  •  
Stacey DavisMcPhee
  •  
Darcey Adams
  •  
Optum
  •  
Nachimson
  •  
Cambia
  •  
Optum
  •  
BCBS TN
  •  
David DeRoode Lantana
  •  

Lora Redden

Texas Health Resources
  •  
CAQH
  •  

David Potochniak


  •  
CMS
  •  
Optum
  •  
Cerner
  •  
Optum
  •  

Teresa McSpadden

Providence
  •    
Dawn Duchek
  •  
Mara DiSalvo 
  •  
AHA
  •  
Cognizant
  •  


  •  

  •  
Acumen
  •  
Evernorth
  •  
Surescripts
  •  

Don Quackenbush


  •  

Mary McKee

Turquoise Health
  •  


  •  
Change Healthcare
  •  


  •  
Providence
  •  

Elissa Dines

CMS/CCIIO
  •  
Financial Mgmt Group at HL7
  •  

Tom Frame

BCBS FL
  •  
Evernorth
  •  

Meryl Bloomrosen

AMA
  •  
BCBS AL
  •  

Emily Ames

CMS/CCIIO


  •  

Travis Higgins


  •  
Consumers' Checkbook/Center for the Study of Services
  •  
Peraton
  •  
Tye MurphyFlorida Blue
  •  
Eric RutledgeSmile Digital Health
  •  
UC Davis
  •  
POCP
  •  

Erin McCarthy


  •  
Availity
  •  
Stratametrics
  •  
Evernorth
  •  
Change Healthcare
  •  

Virgil Bretz

MacroHealth
  •  
Florida Blue
  •  
Availity
  •  

Wendi Moy Akin

CMS/CCIIO
  •  

Heather McComas

AMA
  •  
Mohan DevaragatlaFlorida Blue
  •  
Wendy Gereke AEGIS
  •  
HL7
  •  

Navaya Kadam

Onyx
  •  
Providence
  •  
Ingrid SaldanaHospital for Special Surgery
  •  

Nick Radov 

United Healthcare
  •  


Patient Cost Transparency Supporting Materials